Dedicated Blu-ray players - excluding the PS3 - have been slow to come down in price. This Christmas though, there were quite a few new sub-£200 players on offer, from the new Sharp BD-HὕH to the BDP-S350 from Sony. That doesn’t mean though that there’s aren’t still Blu-ray playersout there designed of offer the best possible HD performance while simultaneously stomping all over your credit card. The Sony BDP-S5000ES [ES stands for 'Elevated Standard] is just one device, sporting an anti-recession price tag of £1,100. Over the break, we managed to get hold of one to see if there’s £900-worth of reasons to buy this over the £200 S350, itself an admirable spinner. The first thing you notice about the S5000ES is that it’s big, like two fat DVD players strapped together. It weighs in at 10KG, making you at least feel like you’re getting more Blu-bang for your buck, so to speak. The reinforced chassis is designed to reduce unwanted vibration during playback. Around the back there’s just about every connection option you might want - although there is no SCART. Still, if you’re spending over £1,100 on the ultimate in HD viewing, connecting anything by SCART is no longer a consideration. Ironically, it has a composite connection [sub-SCART quality] and a bundled cable but no HDMI cable. Why there’s no bundled HDMI cable with a machine this expensive is both a mystery and a disappointment. Jump now to see the main features and connectivity options before we get down to the meaty bit: how does it perform? Key Features: Multimedia guaranteed with BD-ROM/R/RE, DVD-+Video/R/RW, CD Playback, AVCHD Playback 7.1 channel Linear PCM output as well as Dolby TrueHD/DTS-HD bitstream audio output to external AV receivers/decoders 7.1 channel analogue output with Advanced Current Segment Audio D/A converters for legacy AV receivers/decoders Built in BD-Live (Profile 2.0) to immediately enjoy the BD-Live Contents on your Blu-ray Disc™ 1GB of exchangeable storage to save downloaded BD-Live content from the internet HD Reality Enhancer and Super Bit Mapping for greater colour depth and resolution with the latest Full HD TVs With 24p True Cinema you can sit back and watch the film like in real cinema, without length or quality losses High performance 14-bit/297MHz Video D/A converter for superior analogue video output New Precision Cinema HD Upscale technology that converts standard-definition signals (480i) to 1080p and outputs a full HD equivalent resolution signal to 1080p TVs via HDMI™ Frame and beam chassis for rigidity and vibration suppression, and and Precision Drive HD transport mechanism in centre position x.v.Color™ allows to output more natural and vivid colours similar to what the human eye actually sees in the natural world. Gold plated HDMI™ port and other A/V terminals, separate audio board for the best sound quality RS-232C and infrared control inputs OK, once you’ve hooked this up to your TV via [your own] HDMI cable and to a surround sound set-up [we went via optical], it’s time to fire it up. Set-up is painless and the player starts up noticeably quicker than previous Blu-ray players, which could take 2-3 minutes to get up and running. The set-up menus resemble the XMB crossbar from the PS3, which makes it a doddle for PS3 users to use and straightforward for newbies. The remote is chunky but easy to use and illuminates in the dark. We popped in a few discs to test it out, from Planet Earth to Wall-E, via a little Walk Hard: The Dewey Cox Story. Alarmingly, you get a message that states that loading the movie could take 2-3 minutes but, in reality, takes a lot less. Still, why is Blu-ray hardware so slow? Even though the S5000ES was reasonably quick, the same movies loaded faster in the PS3. Once things are up and running, you really do get to see what the whole high-def ‘fuss is all about. There is simply no comparison between a DVD image - even an upscaled one - and a 1080p Full HD image. The clarity is astounding and colour reproduction is rich and deep without any smearing or blurring. Motion video is handled very well by the 14-bit HD Reality Enhancer processor so that you don’t get any jagged cuts as things on screen speed up. The support for 24fps [frames per second] playback also helps here and, of course, at 24fps you get to see the movie the way the director intended. The picture quality truly is top notch. The S5000ES also sports some mean upscaling technology which we tested with some of the updated Stars Wars DVDs, namely A New Hope. There was a noticeable improvement in picture detail and clarity over running it in our upscaling Philips DVD player and even the PS3, while the blacks of space remained black, not ’slightly grey’. For that extra £900, you’d hope so. On the audio, the S5000ES supports the latest in audio technologies, including Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD, with 7.1 channel Linear PCM output as well as Dolby TrueHD and DTS-HD bitstream audio output to external AV receivers or decoders. There’s also an Ethernet jack for updating the firmware. Overall, the S5000ES is a stunning performer but, we were hard pushed to see what makes it that much better than the £200 S350, or the PS3. We ran Planet Earth Blu-ray discs side by side on 1080p TVs using the same HDMI cables and were hard pressed to see where that £900 had gone. On paper, you can see it’s on the quality of the video and audio processors, and rigid deck design but, when viewing the same material side by side, it was difficult to say which was better. In the end, the only real improvement we could identify was deeper and better colour reproduction - but even then, it was marginal, as both sets of images were stunningly clear and vivid. DVDs looked better though but again, there are very good DVD upscalers out there for a fraction of the cost. The S5000ES is for AV purists only, those who crave those extra HD audio formats and can stomach the financial hit. We can’t, however, argue that this is worth the £900 more than the S350 or the PS3, the latter remaining one of the most robust Blu-ray spinners around. In fact, for 99% of potential Blu-ray shoppers - even those that know a thing or two about decent video - we’d say spend your money on the PS3, S350 or another decent £200-300 player, and save the rest of your cash for all those overpriced Blu-ray movies you’ll end up buying.-Martin Lynch blu-ray movies
